What's the difference between ECMAScript and JavaScript? From what I've deduced, ECMAScript is the standard and JavaScript is the implementation. Is this correct?
502
votes
16 Answers
192
votes
ECMAScript is the language, whereas JavaScript, JScript, and even ActionScript 3 are called "dialects". Wikipedia sheds some light on this.
658
votes
I think a little history lesson is due.
JavaScript was originally named Mocha and changed to Livescript but ultimately became JavaScript.
It's important to note that JavaScript came before ECMAscript and the history will tell you why.
To start from the beginning, JavaScript derived its name from Java and initially Brendan Eich (the creator of JS) was asked to develop a language that resembled Java for the web for Netscape.
Eich, however decided that Java was too complicated with all its rules and so set out to create a simpler language that even a beginner could code in. This is evident in such things like the relaxing of the need to have a semicolon.
After the language was complete, the marketing team of Netscape requested Sun to allow them to name it JavaScript as a marketing stunt and hence why most people who have never used JavaScript think it's related to Java.
About a year or two after JavaScript's release in the browser, Microsoft's IE took the language and started making its own implementations such as JScript. At the same time, IE was dominating the market and not long after Netscape had to shut its project.
Before Netscape went down, they decided to start a standard that would guide the path of JavaScript, named ECMAScript.
ECMAScript had a few releases and in 1999 they released their last version (ECMAScript 3) before they went into hibernation for the next 10 years. During this 10 years, Microsoft dominated the scenes but at the same time they weren't improving their product and hence Firefox was born (led by Eich) and a whole heap of other browsers such as Chrome, Opera.
ECMAScript released its 5th Edition in 2009 (the 4th edition was abandoned) with features such as strict mode. Since then, ECMAScript has gained a lot of momentum and is scheduled to release its 6th Edition in a few months from now with the biggest changes its had thus far.
You can use a list of features for ECMAScript 6 here http://kangax.github.io/es5-compat-table/es6/ and also the browser support. You can even start writing Ecmascript 6 like you do with CoffeeScript and use a compiler to compile down to Ecmascript 5.
Whether ECMAScript is the language and JavaScript is a dialect is arguable, but not important. If you continue to think like this it might confuse you. There is no compiler out there that would run ECMAScript, and I believe JavaScript is considered the Language which implements a standard called ECMAScript.
There are also other noticeable languages that implement ECMAScript such as ActionScript (used for Flash)
175
votes
ECMAScript = ES:
ECMAScript is a Standard for scripting languages.
Languages like Javascript are based on the ECMAScript standard.
ECMA Standard is based on several originating technologies, the most well known being JavaScript (Netscape) and JScript (Microsoft).
ECMA means European Computer Manufacturer’s Association
JavaScript = JS:
JavaScript is the most popular implementation of the ECMAScript Standard.
The core features of Javascript are based on the ECMAScript standard, but Javascript also has other additional features that are not in the ECMA specifications/standard.
ActionScript and JScript are other languages that implement the ECMAScript.
JavaScript was submitted to ECMA for standardization but due to trademark issues with the name Javascript the standard became called ECMAScript.
Every browser has a JavaScript interpreter.
ES5 = ECMAScript 5:
ES5 is a version of the ECMAScript (old/current one).
ES5 is the JavaScript you know and use in the browser today.
ES5 does not require a build step (transpilers) to transform it into something that will run in today's browsers.
ECMAScript version 5 was finished in December 2009, the latest versions of all major browsers (Chrome, Safari, Firefox, and IE) have implemented version 5.
Version 5.1 was finished in June, 2011.
ES6 = ECMAScript 6 = ES2015 = ECMAScript 2015:
ES2015 is a version of the ECMAScript (new/future one).
Officially the name ES2015 should be used instead of ES6.
ES6 will tackle many of the core language shortcomings addressed in TypeScript and CoffeeScript.
ES6 is the next iteration of JavaScript, but it does not run in today's browsers.
There are quite a few transpilers that will export ES5 for running in browsers.
BabelJS:
BabelJS is the most popular transpiler that transforms new JavaScript ES6 to Old JavaScript ES5.
BabelJS makes it possible for writing the next generation of JavaScript today (means ES2015).
BabelJS simply takes ES2015 file and transform it into ES5 file.
Current browsers versions can now understand the new JavaScript code (ES2015), even if they don't yet support it.
TypeScript and CoffeeScript:
Both provides syntactic sugar on top of ES5 and then are transcompiled into ES5 compliant JavaScript.
You write TypeScript or CoffeeScript then the transpiler transforms it into ES5 JavaScript.
60
votes
JavaScript = ECMAScript + DOM + BOM;
ECMAScript® Language Specification defines all logic for creating and editing objects, arrays, numbers, etc...
DOM (Document Object Model) makes it possible to communicate with HTML/XML documents (e.g.
document.getElementById('id');).BOM (Browser Object Model) is the hierarchy of browser objects (e.g. location object, history object, form elements).
History of JavaScript naming:
Mocha ► LiveScript ► JavaScript ► (part of JS resulted in) ECMA-262 ► ECMAScript ► JavaScript (consists of ECMAScript + DOM + BOM)
43
votes
Technically ECMAScript is the language that everyone is using and implementing -- it is the specification created many years ago when Netscape and Microsoft sat down and attempted to standardise the scripting between JavaScript (Netscape's scripting language) and JScript (Microsoft's).
Subsequently all these engines are ostensibly implementing ECMAScript, however JavaScript (the name) now hangs around for both traditional naming reasons, and as a marketing term by Mozilla for their various non-standard extensions (which they want to be able to actually "version")
31
votes
What is ECMAScript i.e. ES?
ECMAScript is a standard for a scripting language and the Javascript language is based on the ECMAScript standard.
Is Javascript exactly the same as ECMAScript?
- No, Javascript is not exactly equivalent to ECMAScript.
- The core features of Javascript are based on the ECMAScript standard, but Javascript also has other additional features that are not in the ECMA specifications/standard.
JavaScript = ECMAScript + DOM API;
DOM API like: document.getElementById('id');
Do other languages use the ECMAScript standard?
- Yes, there are languages other than JavaScript that also implement the ECMAScript Standard as their core.
- ActionScript (used by Adobe Flash) and JScript (used by Microsoft) are both languages that implement the ECMAScript standard.
Why is it called ECMAScript?
- Javascript was originally created at Netscape, and they wanted to standardize the language. So, they submitted the language to the European Computer Manufacturer’s Association (ECMA) for standardization.
- But, there were trademark issues with the name Javascript, and the standard became called ECMAScript, which is the name it holds today as well.
- Because of trademark issues, Microsoft’s version of the language is called JScript – even though JScript is, at its core, the same language as Javascript.
12
votes
11
votes
i know this is an old post but hopefully this will help someone.
In the 1990’s different versions of js started coming out like javascript from netscape, Js script from Microsoft. So ecmascript was introduced as a standard. But ecmascript forms only a part of javascript which specifies its core syntax,types,objects etc. Probably that explains the inconsistent implementations of javascript across diff. browsers
Reference - Wrox(Professional Javascript For Web Developers)
8
votes
Existing answers paraphrase the main point quite well.
The main point is that ECMAScript is the bare abstract language, without any domain specific extensions, it's useless in itself. The specification defines only the language and the core objects of it.
While JavaScript and ActionScript and other dialects add the domain specific library to it, so you can use it for something meaningful.
There are many ECMAScript engines, some of them are open source, others are proprietary. You can link them into your program then add your native functions to the global object so your program becomes scriptable. Although most often they are used in browsers.
5
votes
4
votes
ECMAScript is a standard for JavaScript, look at these statements from MDN:
JavaScript
JavaScript (JS) is a lightweight interpreted or JIT-compiled programming language with first-class functions. While it is most well-known as the scripting language for Web pages, many non-browser environments also use it, such as node.js, Apache CouchDB and Adobe Acrobat. JavaScript is a prototype-based, multi-paradigm, dynamic language, supporting object-oriented, imperative, and declarative (e.g. functional programming) styles. Read more about JavaScript.
ECMAScript
The standard for JavaScript is ECMAScript. As of 2012, all modern browsers fully support ECMAScript 5.1. Older browsers support at least ECMAScript 3. On June 17, 2015, ECMA International published the sixth major version of ECMAScript, which is officially called ECMAScript 2015, and was initially referred to as ECMAScript 6 or ES6. Since then, ECMAScript standards are on yearly release cycles. This documentation refers to the latest draft version, which is currently ECMAScript 2018.
For more info, visit here
4
votes
Here are my findings:
JavaScript: The Definitive Guide, written by David Flanagan provides a very concise explanation:
JavaScript was created at Netscape in the early days of the Web, and technically, "JavaScript" is a trademark licensed from Sun Microsystems (now Oracle) used to describe Netscape's (now Mozilla's) implementation of the language. Netscape submitted the language for standardization to ECMA and because of trademark issues, the standardized version of the language was stuck with the awkward name "ECMAScript". For the same trademark reasons, Microsoft's version of the language is formally known as "JScript". In practice, just about everyone calls the language JavaScript.
A blog post by Microsoft seems to agree with what Flanagan explains by saying..
ECMAScript is the official name for the JavaScript language we all know and love.
.. which makes me think all occurrences of JavaScript in this reference post (by Microsoft again) must be replaced by ECMASCript. They actually seem to be careful with using ECMAScript only in this, more recent and more technical documentation page.
w3schools.com seems to agree with the definitions above:
JavaScript was invented by Brendan Eich in 1995, and became an ECMA standard in 1997. ECMA-262 is the official name of the standard. ECMAScript is the official name of the language.
The key here is: the official name of the language.
If you check Mozilla 's JavaScript version pages, you will encounter the following statement:
Deprecated. The explicit versioning and opt-in of language features was Mozilla-specific and are in process of being removed. Firefox 4 was the last version which referred to a JavaScript version (1.8.5). With new ECMA standards, JavaScript language features are now often mentioned with their initial definition in ECMA-262 Editions such as ECMAScript 2015.
and when you see the recent release notes, you will always see reference to ECMAScript standards, such as:
The ES2015 Symbol.toStringTag property has been implemented (bug 1114580).
The ES2015 TypedArray.prototype.toString() and TypedArray.prototype.toLocaleString() methods have been implemented (bug 1121938).
Mozilla Web Docs also has a page that explains the difference between ECMAScript and JavaScript:
However, the umbrella term "JavaScript" as understood in a web browser context contains several very different elements. One of them is the core language (ECMAScript), another is the collection of the Web APIs, including the DOM (Document Object Model).
Conclusion
To my understanding, people use the word JavaScript somewhat liberally to refer to the core ECMAScript specification.
I would say, all the modern JavaScript implementations (or JavaScript Engines) are in fact ECMAScript implementations. Check the definition of the V8 Engine from Google, for example:
V8 is Google’s open source high-performance JavaScript engine, written in C++ and used in Google Chrome, the open source browser from Google, and in Node.js, among others. It implements ECMAScript as specified in ECMA-262.
They seem to use the word JavaScript and ECMAScript interchangeably, and I would say it is actually an ECMAScript engine?
So most JavaScript Engines are actually implementing the ECMAScript standard, but instead of calling them ECMAScript engines, they call themselves JavaScript Engines. This answer also supports the way I see the situation.
3
votes
I doubt we'd ever use the word "ECMAScript" if not for the fact that the name "JavaScript" is owned by Sun. For all intents and purposes, the language is JavaScript. You don't go to the bookstore looking for ECMAScript books, do you?
It's a bit too simple to say that "JavaScript" is the implementation. JScript is Microsoft's implementation.
1
votes
JavaScript is one branch of languages formed around the ECMAScript standard. I believe ECMA is the European Computer Manufacturers Association, not that this is really relevant or anything.
Don't forget another popular language formed around the ECMA Script standard is ActionScript, used in Adobe Flash/Flex.
