Timing with random strings of ASCII printables:
from inspect import getsource
from random import sample
import re
from string import printable
from timeit import timeit
pattern_single = re.compile(r'[\W]')
pattern_repeat = re.compile(r'[\W]+')
translation_tb = str.maketrans('', '', ''.join(c for c in map(chr, range(256)) if not c.isalnum()))
def generate_test_string(length):
return ''.join(sample(printable, length))
def main():
for i in range(0, 60, 10):
for test in [
lambda: ''.join(c for c in generate_test_string(i) if c.isalnum()),
lambda: ''.join(filter(str.isalnum, generate_test_string(i))),
lambda: re.sub(r'[\W]', '', generate_test_string(i)),
lambda: re.sub(r'[\W]+', '', generate_test_string(i)),
lambda: pattern_single.sub('', generate_test_string(i)),
lambda: pattern_repeat.sub('', generate_test_string(i)),
lambda: generate_test_string(i).translate(translation_tb),
]:
print(timeit(test), i, getsource(test).lstrip(' lambda: ').rstrip(',\n'), sep='\t')
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
Result (Python 3.7):
Time Length Code
6.3716264850008880 00 ''.join(c for c in generate_test_string(i) if c.isalnum())
5.7285426190064750 00 ''.join(filter(str.isalnum, generate_test_string(i)))
8.1875841680011940 00 re.sub(r'[\W]', '', generate_test_string(i))
8.0002205439959650 00 re.sub(r'[\W]+', '', generate_test_string(i))
5.5290945199958510 00 pattern_single.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
5.4417179649972240 00 pattern_repeat.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
4.6772285089973590 00 generate_test_string(i).translate(translation_tb)
23.574712151996210 10 ''.join(c for c in generate_test_string(i) if c.isalnum())
22.829975890002970 10 ''.join(filter(str.isalnum, generate_test_string(i)))
27.210196289997840 10 re.sub(r'[\W]', '', generate_test_string(i))
27.203713296003116 10 re.sub(r'[\W]+', '', generate_test_string(i))
24.008979928999906 10 pattern_single.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
23.945240008994006 10 pattern_repeat.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
21.830899796994345 10 generate_test_string(i).translate(translation_tb)
38.731336012999236 20 ''.join(c for c in generate_test_string(i) if c.isalnum())
37.942474347000825 20 ''.join(filter(str.isalnum, generate_test_string(i)))
42.169366310001350 20 re.sub(r'[\W]', '', generate_test_string(i))
41.933375883003464 20 re.sub(r'[\W]+', '', generate_test_string(i))
38.899814646996674 20 pattern_single.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
38.636144253003295 20 pattern_repeat.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
36.201238164998360 20 generate_test_string(i).translate(translation_tb)
49.377356811004574 30 ''.join(c for c in generate_test_string(i) if c.isalnum())
48.408927293996385 30 ''.join(filter(str.isalnum, generate_test_string(i)))
53.901889764994850 30 re.sub(r'[\W]', '', generate_test_string(i))
52.130339455994545 30 re.sub(r'[\W]+', '', generate_test_string(i))
50.061149017004940 30 pattern_single.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
49.366573111998150 30 pattern_repeat.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
46.649754120997386 30 generate_test_string(i).translate(translation_tb)
63.107938601999194 40 ''.join(c for c in generate_test_string(i) if c.isalnum())
65.116287978999030 40 ''.join(filter(str.isalnum, generate_test_string(i)))
71.477421126997800 40 re.sub(r'[\W]', '', generate_test_string(i))
66.027950693998720 40 re.sub(r'[\W]+', '', generate_test_string(i))
63.315361931003280 40 pattern_single.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
62.342320287003530 40 pattern_repeat.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
58.249303059004890 40 generate_test_string(i).translate(translation_tb)
73.810345625002810 50 ''.join(c for c in generate_test_string(i) if c.isalnum())
72.593953348005020 50 ''.join(filter(str.isalnum, generate_test_string(i)))
76.048324580995540 50 re.sub(r'[\W]', '', generate_test_string(i))
75.106637657001560 50 re.sub(r'[\W]+', '', generate_test_string(i))
74.681338128997600 50 pattern_single.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
72.430461594005460 50 pattern_repeat.sub('', generate_test_string(i))
69.394243567003290 50 generate_test_string(i).translate(translation_tb)
str.maketrans
& str.translate
is fastest, but includes all non-ASCII characters.
re.compile
& pattern.sub
is slower, but is somehow faster than ''.join
& filter
.