Calling non-transactional method after transaction is rolled back

Question

I've just found some EJB behaviour which looks rather surprizing to me.

Here is the code sample (for sure MyBean, beanA, beanB are EJBs using CMT):

@Stateless
public class MyBean {
    @TransactionAttribute(TransactionAttributeType.REQUIRED)
    public void myMethod(){
         try {
             beanA.methodA(); /* annotated as REQUIRED */
         } catch (Exception e) {
             beanB.methodB(); /* annotated as NOT_SUPPORTED */
         }
    }
}

Lets's say methodA takes more than transaction timeout to execute, so once it returns myMethod receives TransactionRolledbackException, which is successfully caught then in "myMethod".

I would expect "methodB" be called so far, as accordingly with EJB spec it must be called without any transaction context. But actually, the "beanB" proxy simply returns another TransactionRolledbackException, the "methodB" is not executed.

Looking through EJB spec I do not see anything to prove that container should or even might behave that way.

Do I miss something? Any hint would be appreciated.

UPDATE

At least for Websphere, this behaviour appears to be timeout-specific. The "rollbackOnly" flag which for example is set when "methodA" throws a RuntimeException, does not prevent "methodB" from execution. Only timeout flag does.

Tracy Tracy · Accepted Answer · 2018-03-16T19:33:51

The EJB specification does not specifically address this scenario, other than to indicate that once a transaction has been marked for rollback, then "Continuing transaction is fruitless", and for the handling of NOT_SUPPORTED, the specification indicates it "does not prescribe how the container should manage the execution of a method with an unspecified transaction context".

All versions of WebSphere Application Server have taken the approach that the best way to handle the scenario where an EJB method has been marked for rollback only is to prevent all further actions the container has control over, so that the transaction may be rolled back as quickly as possible, ensuring the timely release of resources (such as database locks). Allowing a call to a NOT_SUPPORTED EJB method would result in the marked for rollback transaction being suspended; and thus continue to hold onto resources that could block or already be blocking other transactions. For this reason, WebSphere prevents such activity.

Calling non-transactional method after transaction is rolled back

2 Answers