Your problem is icomoon.tff.
Font files are considered CSS.
The Browser cannot begin rendering the page until all CSS is loaded in to the DOM.
The page actually began rendering at about 1.6 where the purple stripe (DOM Loaded) begins.
The DOM was almost done at 1.563 after the jQuery was parsed.
When the font file is encountered all rendering from 1.6 to 1.85 was scrapped and the Browser started over.
As you can see icomoon.tff starts at 1.863 right between First paint and Start Render.
Move the font file link up in the header or add it. Better, do not use it.
The cache is another problem. Expires is not cache control.
In the HTTP Response Header Cache control Looks like this:
Cache-Control: max-age=31536000, public
You need to set cache control in .htaccess or in the server configuration
<FilesMatch "\.(ico|pdf|flv|jpg|jpeg|png|gif|svg|swf|mp3|vtt|)(\.gz)?$">
Header set Cache-Control "max-age=31536000, public"
</FilesMatch>
jQuery is costing you. If you want to do page design correctly, do not use jQuery. There is nothing on this page that requires jQuery to render. It can easily be done without. As a matter of fact when I disabled JavaScript, the page appeared to render the same.
CSS could be better. It is costing you about 1.5 seconds.
Considering this page could load in about 0.500 seconds or less, it is costing you 3x page load time.
If you were to do the CSS efficiently rather than use other people stuff, the CSS would fit well in the HTML <head><style> and this page would begin rendering before 0.400.
Put it on a good server, GoDaddy sucks, and your page load could be under 0.300. AWS is hard to beat in performance an price. With GoDaddy you are paying too much for too little.
The following times are from webpagetest.org
domElements' => 115,
pageSpeedVersion' => '1.9',
title' => 'Trinitas Designs',
titleTime' => 877,
loadEventStart' => 2646,
loadEventEnd' => 2652,
domContentLoadedEventStart' => 1563,
domContentLoadedEventEnd' => 1808,
lastVisualChange' => 2680,
browser_name' => 'Google Chrome',
browser_version' => '50.0.2661.94',
server_count' => 1,
server_rtt' => 139,
base_page_cdn' => '',
adult_site' => 0,
fixed_viewport' => 1,
score_progressive_jpeg' => 0,
firstPaint' => 1852,
docCPUms' => 1653.611,
fullyLoadedCPUms' => 1887.612,
docCPUpct' => 61,
fullyLoadedCPUpct' => 36,
isResponsive' => -1,
browser_process_count' => 9,
browser_main_memory_kb' => 50872,
browser_other_private_memory_kb' => 71108,
browser_working_set_kb' => 121980,
domInteractive' => 1563,
date' => 1462831114,
SpeedIndex' => 2278,
visualComplete' => 2680,
icomoon.tff
full_url' => 'http://www.trinitasdesigns.com/fonts/fonts/icomoon.ttf?2ym5un',
score_progressive_jpeg' => -1,
load_end' => 2638,
ttfb_start' => '1863',
ttfb_end' => 2033,
download_start' => 2033,
download_end' => 2638,
download_ms' => 605,
all_start' => '1863',
all_end' => 2638,
all_ms' => '775',
