You're actually over the 4095 selector limit for the following file:
http://sytycw.pixelsmithdesign.com/wp-content/themes/sytycw_2015/css/foundation.css
The difference here from your counts is that you need to include the nested levels of rules within the @media declarations.
krisbulman has a version of a simple count script that you can run in DevTools to get the count (I would run it in Chrome so you get the warning; if not it'll only show 4095):
https://gist.github.com/krisbulman/0f5e27bba375b151515d
My output for the URL you posted is as follows:
File: inline <style> tag
Rules: 1
Selectors: 1
--------------------------
File: http://sytycw.pixelsmithdesign.com/wp-content/plugins/candidate-voting/resources/frontend/candidate-voting.css
Rules: 6
Selectors: 6
--------------------------
File: http://sytycw.pixelsmithdesign.com/wp-content/plugins/revslider-5.0/public/assets/css/settings.css
Rules: 220
Selectors: 303
--------------------------
File: inline <style> tag
Rules: 9
Selectors: 12
--------------------------
File: http://sytycw.pixelsmithdesign.com/wp-content/themes/sytycw_2015/css/foundation.css
Rules: 1776
Selectors: 4419
--------------------------
File: http://sytycw.pixelsmithdesign.com/wp-content/plugins/sytycw-manuscripts-1.0.5.1/resources/frontend/sytycw-manuscripts.css
Rules: 1
Selectors: 1
--------------------------
File: inline <style> tag
Rules: 1
Selectors: 1
--------------------------
VM1068:39
********************************
WARNING:
There are 4419 CSS rules in the stylesheet http://sytycw.pixelsmithdesign.com/wp-content/themes/sytycw_2015/css/foundation.css - IE will ignore the last 323 rules!
You could easily test this by adding a new stylesheet that splits out half the rules (I personally just added a style block in IE's dev tools with the last of the rules and saw everything snap into place).