exiting for loop inside generate statement

Question

I am trying using infinite for loop inside generate statement. But the problem is I cannot stop it or exit it using some condition. I used "disable" and "break". Both don't work.

It shows an error :

unexpected token: 'disable'

Please help me solve this problem or suggest an alternative to it. Here is my Verilog code:

module top(a1,a3,wj,d4,d10,d2,dc,dtot);
input [11:0]a1,a3,wj;
input [3:0]d4;
input [9:0]d10;
input [1:0]d2;
input [25:0]dc;
output reg[25:0]dtot;

reg [25:0]dt,error;
reg [11:0]alpha1,alpha3;

genvar i;
generate

    for (i=1;i>0;i=i+1-1)begin:test
    assign a1[11:0]=alpha1[11:0];
    assign a3[11:0]=alpha3[11:0];

    calb_top t1(a1,a3,wj,d4,d10,d2,dc,dt,error,alpha1,alpha3);

    if(error==26'b00000000000000000000000000)begin
    disable test;
    //break;
    end

end
endgenerate         
assign dtot=dt;
endmodule

wilcroft wilcroft · Accepted Answer · 2015-06-07T14:34:58

Verilog generate block are used to describe physical hardware. As such, an inifinite loop in a generate block will require infinite resources.

Any for loop inside a generate statement must be of a fixed and finite size that can be determined during synthesis.

Remember that HDL is not executed sequentially, but describes connections between physical circuits. Since it appears that you only require one instance of the calb_top module, you don't require either the generate block or the for loop.

Edit: Since you're intending to perform an iterative process, you have two options, as Greg pointed out in his comment below - you can either instantiate a fixed number of calb_top blocks (since an infinite number would require an infinite amount of space) or to re-use the same block some number of times.

Here are some samples. I've haven't sim'd or synthesized them, but they're logically correct.

N-Block solution

module top(a1,a3,wj,d4,d10,d2,dc,dtot,clock,done);

parameter NUM_BLOCKS = 10;

input [11:0]a1,a3,wj;
input [3:0]d4;
input [9:0]d10;
input [1:0]d2;
input [25:0]dc;
output [25:0]dtot;

wire [11:0] a1s [NUM_BLOCKS:0];
wire [11:0] a3s [NUM_BLOCKS:0];
wire [25:0] dt [NUM_BLOCKS-1:0];
wire [25:0] error [NUM_BLOCKS-1:0];

assign a1s[0]=a1;
assign a3s[0]=a3;

genvar i;
generate

    for (i=0;i<NUM_BLOCKS;i=i+1)begin:test
    calb_top t1(a1s[i],a3s[i],wj,d4,d10,d2,dc,dt[i],error[i],a1s[i+1],a3s[i+1]);

    end
endgenerate   

assign dtot=dt[NUM_BLOCKS-1];

endmodule

This links together a number of calb_top blocks equal to NUM_BLOCKS, then outputs the result of the final block to dtot. This doesn't do any checks on the error, so you may want to put in your own code to check error[NUM_BLOCKS-1] (the error of the final calb_top).

Single-Block solution:

module top(clock,start,a1,a3,wj,d4,d10,d2,dc,dtot);
input clock;
input start;
input [11:0]a1,a3,wj;
input [3:0]d4;
input [9:0]d10;
input [1:0]d2;
input [25:0]dc;
output reg[25:0]dtot;

wire [25:0]dt,error;
reg [11:0] a1in, a3in;
wire [11:0] alpha1,alpha3;

calb_top t1(a1in,a3in,wj,d4,d10,d2,dc,dt,error,alpha1,alpha3);

always @(posedge clock)
begin
    if (start)
    begin
        a1in <= a1;
        a3in <= a3;
    end
    else
    begin
        a1in <= alpha1;
        a3in <= alpha3;
    end
end

always @(posedge clock)
    if (start)
        dtot <= 0;
    else if (error == 0)
        dtot <= dt;
    else
        dtot <= dtot;


endmodule

Each clock cycle, we run one pass through calb_top. If start is 1, then a1 and a3 are used as inputs. Otherwise, the previous outputs alpha1 and alpha3 are used. When error is 0, then dtot is set. Note that I've added clock and start to the port list.

exiting for loop inside generate statement

1 Answers