Regardless of what I do in SharePoint 2010, one of my calculated columns show date as a long integer. Please see screenshot.

My formula is below and it doesn't seem to respect it. I changed the column from date time to date. Created a new task and you see the date populates as I would want it on one of the tasks; but it doesn't for my older list items. Please advise.
=IF([Move to MTR2 Date]<>"",TEXT([Move to MTR2 Date],"mm/dd/yy"),IF([Move to MTR2?]=TRUE,"Requested",""))