15
votes

I am trying over-plot some empirical data with error bars on top of my modelled data. The error bars seem to be rendering first and are consequently getting over written (see below)

I have tried using zorder but I still get the same result. The code I am using is

    for i in range(1,len(pf)):
            pf[i,:] = av_pf_scale * pf[i,:]
            pylab.semilogy(pf[0,0:180],pf[i,0:180],color='0.75')

    pylab.semilogy(av_pf[0:180],color='r')
    pylab.semilogy(av_mie[0:180],color='g', linestyle='-')

    pylab.draw()
    f = pylab.errorbar(ang,data[j],
                            yerr = delta_data[j],
                            fmt = 'o',
                            markersize = 3,
                            color = 'b',
                            zorder = 300,
                            antialiased = True)

I would appreciate if anyone can tell me how to make the errorbars render on top.

Mulitplot

2
Could you provide a clearer example? I'm looking hard at your plot and I can see blue error line bars above the other data (they are above the grey mess and the red and green lines). The values seem to be relatively small and so don't have visible verticals, but that's in the data not matplotlib. - danodonovan
Have you tried increasing the zorder beyond 300? Also it's odd that the ends of the errorbars are being rendered above the gray lines, but not the lines. (also watch for negative lower error bounds on your first and last data points.) - ebarr
alternatively, try setting the zorder of the gray lines to be -100. - tacaswell
+1 Good question! In the future, it is better to give examples of your problem that other people can run without needing access to your data (see my examples in my answer) sscce.org . - tacaswell
Thanks, that is good advice. In the future I will do. - Caustic

2 Answers

16
votes

This looks like it is a bug in matplotlib where the zorder argument of the errorbar is not correctly passed to the vertical lines part of error bars.

replicates your problem :

import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
fig = plt.figure()
ax = plt.gca()
[ax.plot(rand(50),color='0.75') for j in range(122)];
ax.errorbar(range(50),rand(50),yerr=.3*rand(50))
plt.draw()

error bar fail Hacky work around:

fig = plt.figure()
ax = plt.gca()
[ax.plot(rand(50),color='0.75',zorder=-32) for j in range(122)];
ax.errorbar(range(50),rand(50),yerr=.3*rand(50))
plt.draw()

error bar hack

report as an issue to matploblib https://github.com/matplotlib/matplotlib/issues/1622 (now patched and closed)

0
votes

This is a known bug in matplotlib. Link to github issue

Hacky solution: Add the argument zorder=3 when you call plt.errorbar, like plt.errorbar(..., zorder=3)