I'm playing with Mutex in freeRTOS using esp32. in some documents i have read that mutex guarantee ownership, which mean if a thread (let's name it task_A) locks up a critical resource (take token) other threads (task_B and task_C) will stay in hold mode waiting for that resource to be unlocked by the same thread that locked it up(which is task_A). i tried to prove that by setting up the other tasks (task_B and task_C) to give a token before start doing anything and just after that it will try to take a token from the mutex holder, which is surprisingly worked without showing any kid of error. Well, the method i used to verify or display how things works i created a display function that read events published (set and cleared) by each task (when it's in waiting mode it set the waiting bit up if it's working it will set the working bit up etc..., you get the idea). and a simple printf() in case of error in take or give function ( xSemaphoreTake != true and xSemaphoreGive != true).
I can't use the debug mode because i don't have any kind of micro controller debugger.
This is an example of what i'm trying to do: i created many tasks and each one will call this function but in different time with different setup.
void vVirtualResource(int taskId, int runTime_ms){
int delay_tick = 10;
int currentTime_tick = 0;
int stopTime_tick = runTime_ms/portTICK_PERIOD_MS;
if(xSemaphoreGive(xMutex)!=true){
printf("Something wrong in giving first mutex's token in task id: %d\n", taskId);
}
while(xSemaphoreTake(xMutex, 10000/portTICK_PERIOD_MS) != true){
vTaskDelay(1000/portTICK_PERIOD_MS);
}
// notify that the task with <<task id>> is currently running and using this resource
switch (taskId)
{
case 1:
xEventGroupClearBits(xMutexEvent, EVENTMASK_MUTEXTSK1);
xEventGroupSetBits(xMutexEvent, EVENTRUN_MUTEXTSK1);
break;
case 2:
xEventGroupClearBits(xMutexEvent, EVENTMASK_MUTEXTSK2);
xEventGroupSetBits(xMutexEvent, EVENTRUN_MUTEXTSK2);
break;
case 3:
xEventGroupClearBits(xMutexEvent, EVENTMASK_MUTEXTSK3);
xEventGroupSetBits(xMutexEvent, EVENTRUN_MUTEXTSK3);
break;
default:
break;
}
// start running the resource
while(currentTime_tick<stopTime_tick){
vTaskDelay(delay_tick);
currentTime_tick += delay_tick;
}
// gives back the token
if(xSemaphoreGive(xMutex)!=true){
printf("Something wrong in giving mutex's token in task id: %d\n", taskId);
}
}
You will notice that for the very first time, the first task that will start running in the processor will print out the first error message because it can't give a token while there still a token in the mutex holder, it's normal, so i just ignore it.
Hope someone can explain to me how mutex guarantee ownership using code in freeRTOS. In the first place i didn't use the first xSemaphoreGive function and it worked fine. but that doesn't mean it guarantee anything. or i'm not coding right.
Thank you.