16
votes

In my Android app, I want to add a Bundle including a Place object described below to my Intent. Since serializable was slow and not recommended, I preferred Parcelable.

Althoug I use Kotlin 1.3.31, I have problems parcelizing some data classes. Example:

import android.os.Parcelable
import kotlinx.android.parcel.Parcelize

@Parcelize
data class Place(val street: String, val postal: String, val city: String) : Parcelable

and Android Studio complains:

Class 'Place' is not abstract and does not implement abstract member public abstract fun writeToParcel(p0: Parcel!, p1: Int): Unit defined in android.os.Parcelable

According to some tutorials

That’s it! You don’t need to write any parcel methods anymore!

https://android.jlelse.eu/yet-another-awesome-kotlin-feature-parcelize-5439718ba220

and I do not want to use

androidExtensions {
    experimental = true
}

in production stuff.

What alternatives would I have here?

3
Why don't you want to use "experimental = true"? It is a requirement for it to work!theblitz
Most companies do not allow to use experimental features in their apps. JetBrains has to move this out of experimental, and work withoutNoam Silverstein
Check my updated answer! :DSome random IT boy

3 Answers

26
votes

UPDATE 19/11/2019

After the stable release of Kotlin 1.3.60 and its corresponding Android Studio plugin the issue is no more. Let's celebrate

UPDATE 27/08/2019

After a bit of more researching and testing with the brand new Kotlin 1.3.50 seems that the issue is going to be finally fully addressed when they release Kotlin 1.3.60 as per this YouTrack issue

EDIT 19/06/2019

With Kotlin 1.3.40 release the @Parcelize annotation is out of experimental and works quite nicely. The only issue is a reported issue that makes the IDE go red, leaving this to a side the code does compile and run perfectly.

Sample code

Sample code

Sample code

I have also tested with this kind of objects and it does also work:

enter image description here

Old answer

I'm facing the exact same issue and while investigating I found this:

Jake Wharton on parcelize

So the looks like the @Parcelize annotation will be fully stable starting from Kotlin 1.3.40. Until then you will have to set the experimental flag. (Sadly)


They have wrongly pushed @Parcelize outside experimental features and you still get that compilation error.

4
votes

In my scenario, I have already using the Kotlin plugin version latest than 1.3.40 version.

But I still got the Android Studio Error, compile success, but IDE complain about the @Parcelize annotation.

Maybe you got this aswell.

Here is the solution.

Check your kotlin plugin version which you are configured in Gradle is the same version which bundled in Android Studio.

I got the error because my Gradle koltin plugin version is 1.3.61 and the Android Studio bundled version is 1.3.50

enter image description here

enter image description here

How to upgrade the Kotlin plugin version?

Tools -> Kotlin -> Configure kotlin plugin update

check the latest version and install, keep the two versions are the same.

enter image description here

0
votes

You can always just implement Parcelable(cmd+enter/alt+enter on class name -> `Add Parcelable Implementation" in order for IDE to create method schemas for you) if you dont' want to/can't use experimental extensions.

I've, however, been using @Parcelize in prod environment(after a lot of testing though) for over a year, with no issues.(Just an opinion though, not saying you should)