VLOOKUP is your real problem here :D
But, assuming that you want to use VLOOKUP, you've defined your ranges wrong, and @nutsch is correct:
=VLOOKUP(B1,Sheet1!A:H,2,FALSE)
or
=VLOOKUP(B1,[Statistics],2,FALSE)
if [Statistics] is defined as the entire table. You must use "2" to call for the "runs" because that's how VLOOKUP works (it counts the number of Columns in the array you define - it doesn't care what you name things).
Now, say you're tired of using column numbers and you WANT to use your ranges. Then we look at Index/Match.
Index/Match
Index() is going to help us find our answer, while Match() helps us do the matching part. In cell TheBest!B2, you'd put:
=INDEX(Sheet1!B:B,MATCH(B1,Sheet1!A:A,0))
or
=INDEX([Runs],MATCH(B1,[Greyhound],0))
if you're using named ranges (where [Greyhound] is Column A in the first screen shot and [Runs] is Column B in the same screenshot.) The 0 in the Match equation is how we find the EXACT match as well.
Interestingly, I note that your output sheet is just turning the data on its side.
You could use a PivotTable here, or you could even design a single equation that would work for all cells with Index/Match/Match.
Index/Match/Match
Index() can let you define the rows as well as the columns, so let's do that too!
=INDEX(Sheet1!A1:H100,MATCH(B$1,Sheet1!A:A,0),MATCH($A2,Sheet1!1:1,0))
or, if I'm assuming that [Statistics] is the whole table and [Greyhound] is Column A and [Headers] is Row 1,
=INDEX([Statistics],MATCH(B$1,[Greyhound],0),MATCH($A2,[Headers],0))
You could drag this equation down B2:B8 on your reporting page and it should work fine, regardless of which dog is shown in B1.
None of this should care if your Statistics array is referencing the dog name with =Top50Graded!A3.
TheBest!A2
) it works perfecly, but I can't search by the dog's name. – thiggy01