Generics in Delphi and returning a reference to tlist<class>

Question

I still use Delphi XE4 (newest compiler I use of multiple Delphi compilers) and need a specific workaround for the fact they completely hid FClients in TBasicAction in this version. I connect/disconnect clients runtime while setting enabled/disabled (to avoid flicker with ~100+ actions and ui elements) thus this workaround for XE4:

Here's my naive attempt and simply returning the field.

  TmscBasicActionCrack = class(TBasicAction)
  end;
{$IFDEF mymsDELPHIXE4}
  TmscBasicActionHelper = class helper for TBasicAction
  public
    function Helper_Get_Private_FClients: TList<System.Classes.TBasicActionLink>;
  end;
{$ENDIF}

{$IFDEF mymsDELPHIXE4}
//------------------------------------------------------------------------------
function TmscBasicActionHelper.Helper_Get_Private_FClients: TList<System.Classes.TBasicActionLink>;
begin
  Result := Self.FClients;
end;
{$ENDIF}

However, I get error

E2003 Undeclared identifier: TList<>

I must admit I never go around to using generics with Delphi since I initially heard of stability problems + I need to maintain compability with Lazarus/FreePascal.

I am aware the most recent versions Delphi has altered class helpers again, but I am for now mostly interested in getting this to work with Delphi XE4

If you ever upgrade to Berlin or higher, your class helper will no longer work as-is, you would have to re-write it (see How to access a private field from a class helper in Delphi 10.1 Berlin?). You should find a different solution to your problem. Why do you need direct access to the FClients list at all? It is private for a reason. — Remy Lebeau
I have a rather convoluted setup where 100+ actions are set enabled/disabled in onidle ... now unfortunately the rules are a bit complex (also partly riddled with defines since I have 6 different tools compiling/using exact same project and code) and some actions can be set twice (yes, I could create boolean values for all actions, work on them and then set actions) - that causes flicker in toolbars. My solution long ago was to disattach actions from their UI elements while updating the action states. — Tom
You should be updating the action states in the OnUpdate event of the individual actions, or in the OnUpdate event of the TActionManager, but not in the Application.OnIdle event itself. Also look at the TApplication.ActionUpdateDelay property (which is 0 by default). — Remy Lebeau
Thanks - I will try see if those are available in Lazarus as well ror maybe use those you list for Delphi in defines - I use the same codebase + forms for Delphi and Lazarus (Using Lazarus for targeting Mac) — Tom

J... J... · Accepted Answer · 2017-04-10T12:02:09

The error is indicating that the TList<T> type is unknown to the compiler. To use it you must include System.Generics.Collections in your uses clause.

Generics in Delphi and returning a reference to tlist<class>

1 Answers