Syntax Error with `<` in Coq Notations

Question

The following code:

Reserved Notation "g || t |- x < y" (at level 10).

Inductive SubtypeOf :
  GammaEnv -> ThetaEnv -> UnsafeType -> UnsafeType -> Set :=
| SubRefl :
    forall (gamma : GammaEnv) (theta : ThetaEnv) (u : UnsafeType) , gamma || theta |- u < u
where "g || t |- x < y" := (SubtypeOf g t x y).

gives the following error:

Syntax error: '<' expected after [constr:operconstr level 200] (in [constr:operconstr])

I get a similar error if I use <: in place of <.

But this code works fine:

Reserved Notation "g || t |- x << y" (at level 10).

Inductive SubtypeOf :
  GammaEnv -> ThetaEnv -> UnsafeType -> UnsafeType -> Set :=
| SubRefl :
    forall (gamma : GammaEnv) (theta : ThetaEnv) (u : UnsafeType) , gamma || theta |- u << u
where "g || t |- x << y" := (SubtypeOf g t x y).

Why? Is there a precedence setting that can be changed to allow < or <: in notation? Is there built-in syntax that I'm colliding with, and need to watch for when defining notations?

Anton Trunov Anton Trunov · Accepted Answer · 2017-02-15T08:17:14

Coq uses an LL1 parser to process notations. It also can output the grammar. So, let's check what we are getting with the following

Reserved Notation "g || t |- x < y" (at level 10).

Print Grammar constr. outputs:

...
| "10" LEFTA
  [ SELF;
    "||";
    constr:operconstr LEVEL "200";        (* subexpression t *)
    "|-";
    constr:operconstr LEVEL "200";        (* subexpression x *)
    "<";
    NEXT
...

Here,

10 is our precedence level;
LEFTA means left associativity;
200 is the default precedence level for inner subexpressions.

Taking into account the fact that a lower level binds more tightly than a higher level and the fact that the level of < is 70 (see Coq.Init.Notations), we can deduce that Coq is trying to parse the x < y part as a subexpression for x, consuming the < token, hence the error message.

To remedy the situation we can explicitly disallow parsing the third parameter as the less-than expression by assigning x higher precedence, i.e. a lower level.

Reserved Notation "g || t |- x < y" (at level 10, x at level 69).

Print Grammar constr.

| "10" LEFTA
  [ SELF;
    "||";
    constr:operconstr LEVEL "200";        (* subexpression t *)
    "|-";
    constr:operconstr LEVEL "69";         (* subexpression x *)
    "<";
    NEXT

Syntax Error with `<` in Coq Notations

1 Answers