Now with Azure Service fabric, would there be a use-case for also using a separate queue solution such as Windows Service Bus? The downsides would probably be a new single point of failure, but are there upsides? Queues can add some buffering, but on the other hand, Service Fabric should be able to scale really well and offer stateful capabilities, so no queue buffers should be needed?
2 Answers
16
votes
Sure, the upside is that services like Azure Service Bus and Azure Storage Queues offer features that are not included out-of-the-box in Service Fabric. So the question to ask yourself is: do you add an external service dependency to get that functionality, or do you stay self-contained by building it yourself on Service Fabric? A self-contained application on Service Fabric is good, but re-inventing existing functionality is bad, so you have to decide where the most value is for you and lean in that direction.
For example, think about..
- Portability. An application that is self contained on Service Fabric can be hosted wherever Service Fabric can run, which is pretty much anywhere (Azure, other public clouds, your own machines or data center, etc.).
- No external dependencies means fewer points of failure, a single toolset, and a unified development, deployment, upgrade, and maintenance process.
On the other hand..
- Services like Service Bus offer a rich set of features. Is it worth spending the time building and maintaining the features you need yourself on Service Fabric?
7
votes
Good question! I'm noodling around this as well. In my case I'm using a RabbitMQ cluster for queuing. I wanted to avoid it and was hoping to have Stateful services using Reliable Queues. I exposed a method to add the message to the service and use the RunAsync method to dequeue the messages as they arrive. I'm not impressed with the performance using this approach, compared to a stateless service connecting to RabbitMQ. But before I give up, I'm planning to partition the Stateful service across a 5 nodes and see if there are any performance improvements, using the Stateful services a queue consuming workers.
