Annotation processor needs to process all files when only a subset gets compiled, but how?

Question

I have an annotation processor that looks for files that contain a certain annotation. The output of the processor is a single file, that references each such annotated file.

For example, if classes X, Y, and Z contain the annotation @Foo, then the @Foo processor will generate a file like:

class FooFiles {

  Class[] getFooClasses() {
    return new Class[]{X.class,Y.class,Z.class};
  }

}

This works fine if I do a mvn clean compile, since all classes are compiled and passed to the annotation processor.

But if the classes are up to date, and I modify just one (say the X class), then a mvn compile will perform an incremental build, and since only X class is compiled, then only the X class gets passed to the annotation processor, and the generated file is:

class FooFiles {

  Class[] getFooClasses() {
    return new Class[]{X.class};
  }

}

This is bad.

I'm using maven with maven-compiler-plugin version 2.5.1, which seems to do incremental compilation.

If I update the maven-compiler-plugin to version 3.1, then any change in one file results in compilation of all files, and this problem does not occur (although compiling all files when only one file has changed may not be the solution here, other developers will complain when a module with 10K+ files needs to recompiled from scratch because of one file change). I did try setting the useIncrementalCompilation option to true in the plugin's configuration, but it seems to recompile all files regardless.

I modified my annotation processor so that it does not overwrite any existing generated file. This means that after a clean then the correct provider file is generated containing X,Y, and Z references. But if just X changes, for example, then a new provider file is not generated. This allows incremental compilation, but at the expense of remembering to do a clean where necessary.

I'm not sure if there's a general solution here, but I'm asking anyway. I guess what I really want is for the annotation processor to run over the target/classes directory after the compile phase. I might need to write a maven plugin for that, perhaps.

kapex kapex · Accepted Answer · 2014-11-26T03:17:08

There is a bug in maven-compiler-plugin version 3.1. that causes incremental builds to fail. Currently the latest version is 3.2 anyway.

This is bad.

Only because it breaks your current processor. As you noted yourself, it's not the best solution to rebuilt everything all the time. A better approach would be to support incremental builds. This will make builds faster and your processor compatible with more compilers, IDEs and build tools. You probably need a new way to handle your annotated classes though.

Here is a thought how you could go about supporting incremental builds.

Instead of collecting all classes in a single place like FooFiles, you generate a resource file that will list all your classes and then add each annotated class you encounter on an incremental built. Whenever FooFiles needs to be used you can read the classes from that resource file. You also need to remove classes in your list that have been deleted or aren't annotated anymore.

It won't be that easy if your processor is more complex but I the general approach should still work. You could also generate a classes for each annotated class, that dynamically registers itself somewhere, if properties files aren't enough.

Annotation processor needs to process all files when only a subset gets compiled, but how?

1 Answers