Is the Writer Monad effectively the same as the State Monad?

21
votes

There's a great tutorial here that seems to suggest to me that the Writer Monad is basically a special case tuple object that does operations on behalf of (A,B). The writer accumulates values on the left (which is A) and that A has a corresponding Monoid with it (hence it can accumulate or mutate state). If A is a collection, then it accumulates.

The State Monad is also a object that deals with an internal tuple. They both can be flatMap'd, map'd, etc. And the operations seem the same to me. How are they different? (please respond back with a scala example, I'm not familiar with Haskel). Thanks!

2
scalamonadsscalazstate-monadwriter-monad

2 Answers

39
votes

Your intuition that these two monads are closely related is exactly right. The difference is that Writer is much more limited, in that it doesn't allow you to read the accumulated state (until you cash out at the end). The only thing you can do with the state in a Writer is tack more stuff onto the end.

More concisely, State[S, A] is a kind of wrapper for S => (S, A), while Writer[W, A] is a wrapper for (W, A).

Consider the following usage of Writer:

import scalaz._, Scalaz._

def addW(x: Int, y: Int): Writer[List[String], Int] =
  Writer(List(s"$x + $y"), x + y)

val w = for {
  a <- addW(1, 2)
  b <- addW(3, 4)
  c <- addW(a, b)
} yield c

Now we can run the computation:

scala> val (log, res) = w.run
log: List[String] = List(1 + 2, 3 + 4, 3 + 7)
res: Int = 10

We could do exactly the same thing with State:

def addS(x: Int, y: Int) =
  State((log: List[String]) => (log |+| List(s"$x + $y"), x + y))

val s = for {
  a <- addS(1, 2)
  b <- addS(3, 4)
  c <- addS(a, b)
} yield c

And then:

scala> val (log, res) = s.run(Nil)
log: List[String] = List(1 + 2, 3 + 4, 3 + 7)
res: Int = 10

But this is a little more verbose, and we could also do lots of other things with State that we couldn't do with Writer.

So the moral of the story is that you should use Writer whenever you can—your solution will be cleaner, more concise, and you'll get the satisfaction of having used the appropriate abstraction.

Very often Writer won't give you all the power you need, though, and in those cases State will be waiting for you.

1
votes

tl;dr State is Read and Write while Writer is, well, only write.

With State you have access to the previous data stored and you can use this data in your current computation:

def myComputation(x: A) =
  State((myState: List[A]) => {
        val newValue = calculateNewValueBasedOnState(x,myState)
        (log |+| List(newValue), newValue)
  })

With Writer you can store data in some object you don't have access to, you can only write to that object.