Multiple ways of declaring dependencies in Maven IntelliJ projects

3
votes

In new Maven projects in IntelliJ, I see 2 ways of declaring new dependencies:

  1. Manually editing the pom.xml file, adding a <dependency/> declaration. This automatically (maven auto-import is on) adds Maven: ... entries to the project .iml file and all is well.
  2. Using the File -> Project Structure -> Dependencies menu. This only creates entries in the .iml file.

This seems like unwanted behavior. IntelliJ doesn't overwrite the .iml file when importing the pom.xml Maven file, but merges dependencies from the pom.xml and additionally-defined ones from the .iml.

I want to enforce a single way of adding dependencies in my team (using pom.xml only, for external mvn builds), and the ability to bypass the pom.xml and directly add dependencies to the .iml creates the illusion of a valid build (when in fact, it is not).

Am I missing something? How can I enforce one way of adding dependencies? Is there a way through which IntelliJ will add dependencies to the pom.xml file instead of the .iml files?

EDIT

In this question (IntelliJ IDEA + Maven what is the need for dependency entries in an iml file?) it is claimed that

This can be also used to experiment with dependencies without changing the pom.xml. Note that all the modifications you make will be reverted on next Maven import.

But this is not the behavior I see. The .iml file doesn't get reverted, but merged.

2
javamavenintellij-ideapom.xml
Why do you consider .iml files ? If your project needs to be compiled across all the IDE then whats the case ? Never depend on .iml which is IDE specific. My suggestion would be add in pom.xml which will make it to work irrespective of the IDE you use. – Vinay Veluri

2 Answers

1
votes

It sounds like you need a continuous integration environment.

This won't stop your team members adding dependencies in the wrong place, but it will ensure that is caught very early and flag it up that they need to add it to your pom, then it just comes down to education.

0
votes

Pom.xml is only to be used by Maven, IntelliJ does pick up the dependencies from the pom.xml if you have configured your IDE properly. If you however, want to use maven solely, you can add the jars to your local maven repo and then call them from your pom.xml normally via the <dependency> tag.

You can learn how to add local jars here.