$unwind empty array

34
votes

I have a collection of users where each document has following structure:

{
  "_id": "<id>",
  "login": "xxx",
  "solved": [
    {
      "problem": "<problemID>",
      "points": 10
    },
    ...
  ]
}

The field solved may be empty or contain arbitrary many subdocuments. My goal is to get a list of users together with the total score (sum of points) where users that haven't solved any problem yet will be assigned total score of 0. Is this possible to do this with a single query (ideally using aggregation framework)?

I was trying to use following query in aggregation framework:

{ "$group": {
  "_id": "$_id",
  "login": { "$first": "$login" },
  "solved": { "$addToSet": { "points": 0 } }
} }
{ "$unwind": "$solved" }
{ "$group": {
  "_id": "$_id",
  "login": { "$first": "$login" },
  "solved": { "$sum": "$solved.points" }
} }

However I am getting following error:

exception: The top-level _id field is the only field currently supported for exclusion

Thank you in advance

2
mongodbaggregation-framework
when you say "solved may be empty" is it present and an empty array or is it absent in case of no problems solved? – Asya Kamsky
also, $first login gets the first value (by order of array) - is that what you want, or do you want $min? If no problems are solved, can login be null or missing also? – Asya Kamsky

2 Answers

107
votes

With MongoDB 3.2 version and newer, the $unwind operator now has some options where in particular the preserveNullAndEmptyArrays option will solve this.

If this option is set to true and if the path is null, missing, or an empty array, $unwind outputs the document. If false, $unwind does not output a document if the path is null, missing, or an empty array. In your case, set it to true:

db.collection.aggregate([
    { "$unwind": {
            "path": "$solved",
            "preserveNullAndEmptyArrays": true
    } },
    { "$group": {
        "_id": "$_id",
        "login": { "$first": "$login" },
        "solved": { "$sum": "$solved.points" }
    } }
])
8
votes

Here is the solution - it assumes that the field "solved" is either absent, is equal to null or has an array of problems and scores solved. The case it does not handle is "solved" being an empty array - although that would be a simple additional adjustment you could add.

project = {$project : {
        "s" : {
            "$ifNull" : [
                "$solved",
                [
                    {
                        "points" : 0
                    }
                ]
            ]
        },
        "login" : 1
    }
};
unwind={$unwind:"$s"};
group= { "$group" : {
        "_id" : "$_id",
        "login" : {
            "$first" : "$login"
        },
        "score" : {
            "$sum" : "$s.points"
        }
    }
}

db.students.aggregate( [ project, unwind, group ] );