I have a simple VHDL design and test bench that does not produce the expected output. ISim shows 'U' for all the outputs until the 'running' state is achieved (myState='1'). Then they show 0 and X values. The first PROCESS block should set all outputs to '0' when ENABLE is '0'. The test bench toggles ENABLE 0-1-0 to insure an event triggers the process, but the outputs stay at 'U'. Is the problem in the design, the test, or both?
VHDL
library IEEE;
use IEEE.STD_LOGIC_1164.ALL;
entity TestHarness1 is
port (
ADAT_WDCLK : in std_logic;
ADAT_BCLK: in std_logic;
ADAT_OUT12: in std_logic;
ENABLE: in std_logic;
PCM_FS : out std_logic;
PCM_CLK : out std_logic;
PCM_DIN : out std_logic
);
end TestHarness1;
architecture Behavioral of TestHarness1 is
--type state is (STOPPED, RUNNING);
signal tmp : std_logic;
signal myState : std_logic;
begin
PCM_DIN <= tmp;
-- State management process
process (ENABLE, ADAT_WDCLK) begin -- Eval on input changes
if (ENABLE = '0') then
myState <= '0'; --STOPPED;
PCM_FS <= '0'; -- All outputs muted
PCM_CLK <= '0';
tmp <= '0';
else
if (myState = '0' and rising_edge(ADAT_WDCLK)) then
-- Move to running state only at start of a frame
myState <= '1'; --RUNNING;
end if;
end if;
end process;
-- Output process
process (ADAT_WDCLK, ADAT_BCLK, myState) variable counter: integer := 0; begin
-- Only do something if we are in running state, process above
-- sets outputs when stopped.
if (myState = '1') then
-- Pass the clocks through, inverting the bit clock
PCM_FS <= ADAT_WDCLK;
PCM_CLK <= not ADAT_BCLK;
-- Generate fixed bit pattern data '11000101'
if rising_edge(ADAT_WDCLK) then
-- This would happen naturally since there are 4 bytes per word clock
counter := 0;
end if;
if falling_edge(ADAT_WDCLK) then
-- This would happen naturally since there are 4 bytes per word clock
counter := 0;
end if;
if rising_edge(ADAT_BCLK) then -- Change data state only on falling edge of output PCM_CLK
if counter = 0 or counter = 1 or counter = 5 or counter = 7 then
tmp <= '1';
else
tmp <= '0';
end if;
if (counter = 7) then
counter := 0; -- Reset counter
else
counter := counter + 1; -- Just inc counter
end if;
end if;
end if;
end process;
end Behavioral;
Test Bench
LIBRARY ieee;
USE ieee.std_logic_1164.ALL;
ENTITY TH1TestBench3 IS
END TH1TestBench3;
ARCHITECTURE behavior OF TH1TestBench3 IS
-- Component Declaration for the Unit Under Test (UUT)
COMPONENT TestHarness1
PORT(
ADAT_WDCLK : IN std_logic;
ADAT_BCLK : IN std_logic;
ADAT_OUT12 : IN std_logic;
ENABLE : IN std_logic;
PCM_FS : OUT std_logic;
PCM_CLK : OUT std_logic;
PCM_DIN : OUT std_logic
);
END COMPONENT;
--Inputs
signal ADAT_WDCLK : std_logic := '0';
signal ADAT_BCLK : std_logic := '0';
signal ADAT_OUT12 : std_logic := '0';
signal ENABLE : std_logic := '0';
--Outputs
signal PCM_FS : std_logic;
signal PCM_CLK : std_logic;
signal PCM_DIN : std_logic;
-- Clock period definitions. Note WDCLK is defined in terms of the bit clock
-- to insure they are exactly in sync.
constant ADAT_BCLK_period : time := 326 ns; -- About 3.072MHz (https://www.sensorsone.com/frequency-to-period-calculator/)
constant ADAT_WDCLK_period : time := ADAT_BCLK_period * 64; -- 48KHz
BEGIN
-- Instantiate the Unit Under Test (UUT)
uut: TestHarness1 PORT MAP (
ADAT_WDCLK => ADAT_WDCLK,
ADAT_BCLK => ADAT_BCLK,
ADAT_OUT12 => ADAT_OUT12,
ENABLE => ENABLE,
PCM_FS => PCM_FS,
PCM_CLK => PCM_CLK,
PCM_DIN => PCM_DIN
);
-- Clock process definitions
ADAT_WDCLK_process :process
begin
ADAT_WDCLK <= '0';
wait for ADAT_WDCLK_period/2;
ADAT_WDCLK <= '1';
wait for ADAT_WDCLK_period/2;
end process;
ADAT_BCLK_process :process
begin
ADAT_BCLK <= '1';
wait for ADAT_BCLK_period/2;
ADAT_BCLK <= '0';
wait for ADAT_BCLK_period/2;
end process;
-- Stimulus process
stim_proc: process
begin
-- hold reset state for 100 ns.
wait for 100 ns;
ENABLE <= '1';
wait for 100 ns;
ENABLE <= '0';
wait for 7500 ns;
ENABLE <= '1';
wait for ADAT_WDCLK_period*10;
-- insert stimulus here
wait;
end process;
END;
ISim shows the ENABLE pulse early in the simulation, but the outputs remain 'U' until the rising edge of the WCLK with ENABLE=1. Then they start to change (as designed) but they show some X values.
Modified VHDL
For reference, here is the modified VHDL that resolves the problem of U's and X's in the simulation output. However, there is a functional problem with the PCM_DIN output... seems like it is delayed one (BCLK) cycle. I expected it to be '1' as soon as ADAT_WDCLK goes high the first time after ENABLE. But it does not go to '1' until a BLCK cycle later.
library IEEE;
use IEEE.STD_LOGIC_1164.ALL;
entity TestHarness1 is
port (
ADAT_WDCLK : in std_logic;
ADAT_BCLK: in std_logic;
ADAT_OUT12: in std_logic;
ENABLE: in std_logic;
PCM_FS : out std_logic;
PCM_CLK : out std_logic;
PCM_DIN : out std_logic
);
end TestHarness1;
architecture Behavioral of TestHarness1 is
--type state is (STOPPED, RUNNING);
signal tmp : std_logic;
signal myState : std_logic;
begin
PCM_DIN <= tmp;
-- State management process
process (ENABLE, ADAT_WDCLK) begin -- Eval on input changes
if (ENABLE = '0') then
myState <= '0'; --STOPPED;
else
if (myState = '0' and rising_edge(ADAT_WDCLK)) then
-- Move to running state only at start of a frame
myState <= '1'; --RUNNING;
end if;
end if;
end process;
-- Output process
process (ADAT_WDCLK, ADAT_BCLK, myState) variable counter: integer := 0; begin
-- Only do something if we are in running state
if (myState = '0') then
PCM_FS <= '0'; -- All outputs muted
PCM_CLK <= '0';
tmp <= '0';
elsif (myState = '1') then
-- Pass the clocks through, inverting the bit clock
PCM_FS <= ADAT_WDCLK;
PCM_CLK <= not ADAT_BCLK;
if rising_edge(ADAT_BCLK) then -- Generate fixed serial bit pattern
if counter = 0 or counter = 1 or counter = 5 or counter = 7 then
tmp <= '1';
else
tmp <= '0';
end if;
if (counter = 7) then
counter := 0; -- Reset counter
else
counter := counter + 1; -- Just inc counter
end if;
end if;
end if;
end process;
end Behavioral;
ISim of the above (including the internal myState signal)... why is PCM_DIN delayed one BCLK cycle?
