Clojure reducers library - folding with max

Question

I'm trying to convert the following example to the new Clojure 1.5 reducers library:

(reduce max (map inc (range 10))) 
;=> 10

When I change it- I get the following error:

(r/fold max  (r/map inc (range 10)))
;ArityException Wrong number of args (0) passed to: core$max  clojure.lang.AFn.throwArity (AFn.java:437)

Can someone give me a correct solution?

Jan Jan · Accepted Answer · 2013-01-07T09:28:53

Notice that it works when you substitute max with +.

(r/fold + (r/map inc (range 10)))
; => 55

The difference is the fact that unlike + max does not have a case for an invocation with no arguments. r/fold requires the combining function—i.e. max—to provide an identity value when called without arguments. For * it's 1, for + it's 0.

A potential solution would be to define a max' which acts as max but when called with no arguments it returns the negative infinity—an identity element for the max function.

(defn max'
  ([] Double/NEGATIVE_INFINITY)
  ([& args] (apply max args)))
(r/fold max'  (r/map inc (range 10)))
; => 10

The same result can be achieved using the r/monoid function.

(r/fold (r/monoid max #(Double/NEGATIVE_INFINITY)) (r/map inc (range 10)))

For further discussion see Reducers - A Library and Model for Collection Processing, section Simplicity is Opportunity.

Clojure reducers library - folding with max

1 Answers