68
votes

I understand what Gradient Descent does. Basically it tries to move towards the local optimal solution by slowly moving down the curve. I am trying to understand what is the actual difference between the plan gradient descent and the newton's method?

From Wikipedia, I read this short line "Newton's method uses curvature information to take a more direct route." What does this intuitively mean?

4
curvature relates to how Newton's method uses the fuction's second order derivative. Gradient descent is typically first order.akk
Watch this lecture from start to finish: youtube.com/…ahwillia
Very similar, also with a good answer: math.stackexchange.com/q/1085436/407385rehctawrats

4 Answers

72
votes

At a local minimum (or maximum) x, the derivative of the target function f vanishes: f'(x) = 0 (assuming sufficient smoothness of f).

Gradient descent tries to find such a minimum x by using information from the first derivative of f: It simply follows the steepest descent from the current point. This is like rolling a ball down the graph of f until it comes to rest (while neglecting inertia).

Newton's method tries to find a point x satisfying f'(x) = 0 by approximating f' with a linear function g and then solving for the root of that function explicitely (this is called Newton's root-finding method). The root of g is not necessarily the root of f', but it is under many circumstances a good guess (the Wikipedia article on Newton's method for root finding has more information on convergence criteria). While approximating f', Newton's method makes use of f'' (the curvature of f). This means it has higher requirements on the smoothness of f, but it also means that (by using more information) it often converges faster.

13
votes

Put simply, gradient descent you just take a small step towards where you think the zero is and then recalculate; Newton's method, you go all the way there.

4
votes

Edit 2017: The original link is dead - but the way back machine still got it :) https://web.archive.org/web/20151122203025/http://www.cs.colostate.edu/~anderson/cs545/Lectures/week6day2/week6day2.pdf

this power point the main ideas are explained simply http://www.cs.colostate.edu/~anderson/cs545/Lectures/week6day2/week6day2.pdf

I hope this help :)

1
votes

If you simply compare Gradient Descent and Newton's method, the purpose of the two methods are different.

Gradient Descent is used to find(approximate) local maxima or minima (x to make min f(x) or max f(x)). While Newton's method is to find(approximate) the root of a function, i.e. x to make f(x) = 0

In this sense, they are used to solve different problems. However, Newton's method can also be used in the context of optimization (the realm that GD is solving). Because finding maxima or minima can be approached by finding f'(x) = 0 which is exactly Newton's method is used for.

In conclusion, two methods can be used in optimization: 1)GD and 2)find x so f'(x)=0 and Newton's method is just a way to solve that second problem.